Navigating Medicare Appeals and Grievances In New York

By Brian Krantz - May 23, 2025

part b premium

As a Medicare beneficiary, it’s essential to understand your healthcare rights, including the appeals and grievances processes. This guide will help you effectively navigate these procedures, ensuring you receive the care and coverage you deserve.

Understanding Grievances

Grievances allow you to formally address complaints related to administrative issues, including provider interactions, facility cleanliness, appointment timeliness, and quality of services. You must file grievances within 60 days of the related incident.

Expedited Grievances

In urgent cases where coverage decisions, determinations, or reconsiderations are denied, you may file an expedited grievance to accelerate resolution.

How to File a Grievance

You may appoint someone to represent you (relative, friend, attorney, doctor). To appoint a representative, include:

  • Your name, address, phone number, and Medicare number.
  • Representative’s contact details and a statement authorizing them to act on your behalf.
  • Signatures from you and your representative with acceptance statements and dates.

Understanding Appeals

Appeals enable you to contest coverage decisions that deny, reduce, or discontinue healthcare services or payments. You must file appeals within 60 days of receiving an adverse determination.

Appeals can be filed if:

  • Services requested are denied or limited.
  • Current services are reduced or terminated.
  • Medicare coverage of specific services is refused.

The Five Steps of the Medicare Appeals Process

  1. Redetermination: Submit a written request within 120 days to the Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC).
  2. Reconsideration: Request a review by a Qualified Independent Contractor (QIC) within 180 days if unsatisfied with the redetermination.
  3. Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Hearing: Request an ALJ hearing within 60 days if the reconsideration decision is unfavorable.
  4. Medicare Appeals Council Review: Submit within 60 days if dissatisfied with the ALJ decision.
  5. Judicial Review: File a lawsuit in federal district court if the Medicare Appeals Council review does not resolve your issue satisfactorily.

Filing Appeals for Medicare Health Plans

  • Review your initial denial notice for appeal instructions.
  • Submit your appeal within 60 days, including your personal details, Medicare number, service dates, reasons for appeal, and representative information if applicable.
  • Request an expedited decision if a standard decision timeline (14 days) poses a serious health risk (decision within 72 hours).

Response times:

  • Expedited requests: 72 hours
  • Standard service requests: 30 calendar days
  • Payment requests: 60 calendar days

Filing Appeals for Medicare Prescription Drug Plans

  • Reimbursement: Submit a written reimbursement request with the “Model Coverage Determination Request” form or a letter.
  • Coverage Determinations or Exceptions: Request coverage determinations or exceptions through your plan.
  • Expedited Requests: If urgent, request an expedited response within 24 hours.

Response times:

  • Expedited requests: 24 hours
  • Standard requests: 72 hours
  • Payment requests: 14 calendar days

Outpatient Status Appeal

If a hospital changes your status from inpatient to outpatient (observation), you have appeal rights due to potential impacts on your coverage and costs. The appeal process for this scenario is currently under development.

Grievances vs. Appeals: Key Differences

  • Grievance: Addresses general dissatisfaction or administrative issues unrelated to specific coverage determinations.
  • Appeal: A formal process challenging specific decisions denying, reducing, or discontinuing Medicare-covered services or payments.

Expert Help from Plan Medicare

Navigating Medicare grievances and appeals can be complex. Plan Medicare provides expert guidance to help you manage these processes effectively. For personalized assistance, call 516-900-7877 or schedule your consultation today.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I Appoint a Representative for a Grievance or Appeal?
Yes, you may appoint a representative such as a family member, friend, attorney, or healthcare provider.

What Are Coverage Determinations?
These are decisions your Medicare plan makes about the benefits and services it will cover.

How Do I Navigate the Appeals Process?
Review your plan’s Evidence of Coverage (EOC) and Summary of Benefits for detailed steps and required documentation.

Can I File Late Grievances or Appeals?
Late submissions may be accepted if you provide a valid reason. Check with your Medicare plan for specifics.

 

Speak to a Licensed Advisor in Medicare today

Book an Appointment Call: 516-900-7877